The hardest part is to introduce the tax
Interview by Chris Deschaseaux, for EnergiePlus , No. 400
In the panoply of environmental economists, we usually distinguish three major types of tools, two of which are strictly economic tools. Environmental taxes have been theorized by a British economist Arthur Pigou in 1920 in his book "The economy of welfare" where he posed the problem of already factored into the economic calculation of environmental costs. The solution he proposed was the famous internalisation of external costs. The idea tradable quotas is due to the contribution of Ronald Coase in 1960 on the access rights to the environment. Eight years later, John Dales invented the system of tradable emission allowances first applied to the operating rights of Canada's Forests. Parallel to these economic theories, environmental policies are developed in practice in the 60s, for example through the Clean Air Act in the United States. The question then systems based on standards and standards, what the Americans call "command and control. The state command and control the outcome. This mechanism is reflected today in the language of negotiation climate "policies and measures". For example, the state decides to impose a standard on building a standard energy efficiency of boilers, etc..
None of these tools is perfect. The tax advantage of being economically efficient. Its cost is known but its outcome is not predictable and it is directly not sure that the policy is optimal because socially speaking we should know exactly the marginal cost of pollution and of pollution control.
For the quota system, the problem is reversed. The state gives the quantities of pollution or waste emissions allowed but it is impossible to determine in advance the price of allowances on the market. This is a great uncertainty. Another problem also lies in the initial allocation of quotas to individual economic actors.
In the 1990s, Europeans, at least some of them were rather for taxes and quotas for the Americans instead. The Europeans were so opposed to quotas because they felt the system was not ethical and it was a commodification of nature. At the time, the U.S. was on their side against the principle of the tax. Moreover, they had already implemented a system Trading for SO2 emissions (through an amendment of the Clean Air Act) that worked very well. Then there was a complete reversal of preference between the U.S. and Europeans.
How did it change made?
During negotiations to establish the Kyoto Protocol, the United States has strongly pushed the quota mechanism associated with binding quantitative targets. The Europeans finally realize that the tax may be economically efficient because it is the guarantee of a good proportionality of effort, but in terms of environmental efficiency, quotas may be more suitable because they can directly control the quantities. An instrument originally perceived as very liberal instead becomes the means of regulation much more severe. In Kyoto in 1997, the Europeans finally agreed on a quota system. Americans do the opposite and with political change, they decided in February 2001 to withdraw. Since they refuse any quantitative target. In contrast, Europeans are anchored the quota system and introducing the industrial sector in 2005. The quota system works, the Kyoto Protocol has been consolidated but its future is still uncertain. He stops in 2012 so we need to discuss post 2012. United States, the quantitative reduction targets are back in some states but not in the Speech from the federal government. Before the Bali conference, things have changed a bit. Australia signed the Kyoto Protocol and the United States lose their main ally. Moreover, China
Absolutely, it is important not to see the different devices as mutually exclusive from each other. Policies and measures, as well as technical norms and standards, we need them because they give clear signals to industry to innovate. The European system of quotas has been difficult to construct, do not break it now. It will be further strengthened after 2012 and may form the basis of an international market. One day, this system limited to Europe may be gradually open to other countries more quickly if an agreement on quantitative targets is found. Especially in this system, there are CDM projects which are a very good solution to finance by the northern countries for projects in the South. For all these reasons, I oppose the idea of an international CO2 tax that would replace the quota system, while I support a tax for national or European sectors not covered by the system of quotas. Moreover, it must seriously analyze the idea of a CO2 tax on the borders of Europe, as it would compensate the differential competitiveness of European industries imposed, compared to countries without emission reduction targets.
What do you think of the climate-energy contribution which the principle was adopted at the Round Table?
In France, the emissions of greenhouse gas emissions by big industry and the electrical system are managed by the European quota system for approximately one third of the CO2 emitted. To address the transportation and construction, three types of instruments are possible: tax, individual permits and the quota system upstream. Following the Grenelle building standards for housing is an important achievement, but I think it must also be established a tax, whose exact content is still to be defined. The question would then arise from the use of this tax. Three solutions are possible: pay tax at the general budget of the State, directly affect the financing of investments for energy efficiency and renewable energy own, then redistribute that tax citizens equally. Each option has advantages and disadvantages. The last, the redistribution would be in France a real innovation in this scheme, the consumer pays Fossil energy, but the citizen receives.
The process of implementation of what could be a climate-energy will be under the
It applies, for example, whenever a consumer purchases of gasoline and in the construction industry, every purchase of fossil fuels. Initially, the tax should only take into account the CO2 measured in consumption of fossil energy at the point of emission. So if EDF burning natural gas plant, EDF pays the appropriate fee but not directly to the consumer electricity. Environmental NGOs, however, requested the introduction of a mixed tax (carbon and energy) for nuclear power is not favored. The challenge will then measure the weight of each component.
For the Ministry of Industry and then in a different framework than
If, of course, and these devices may be useful. But if you had come back to a single system, it would be better to choose the tax as its main tool.
Yes, even in principle. But we must be very concerned about the impacts it can have on certain population groups particularly disadvantaged who are often dependent on the car. People living far from their work have no choice. The definition of tax in the process RGPO should clarify this and to provide for related matters, why not a new version of the check transportation companies.
0 comments:
Post a Comment